Marketplaces like Etsy, DoorDash and Booksy are good for getting found, but you shouldn't rely on them alone. Think of them as renting an audience. Your own website is how you own one, so the customers you earn stay yours no matter what the platform decides to change.
That's the short answer. Here's the longer, more practical one.
Renting an audience vs. owning one
When you sell through a marketplace, you're setting up a booth in someone else's building. The building is busy, which is the whole appeal. People are already walking the halls looking for handmade gifts, a quick dinner or a haircut this Saturday.
But it's still their building. They set the rent, they write the rules, they decide where your booth goes, and they can change any of that whenever they want. You're a tenant.
Owning your audience means having a place of your own: a website at your own address, a way for people to book or order directly, and a list of customers you can reach without asking anyone's permission. It's slower to build, but nobody can take it away from you.
Neither one is wrong. The trouble starts when a business is only renting and has nothing it owns.
What marketplaces actually do well
It's worth being fair here. Marketplaces solve real problems, especially early on.
- They bring traffic. People go to these apps already ready to buy. That's hard to create from scratch.
- They handle the boring parts. Payments, scheduling tools, delivery logistics and reminders are often built in.
- They build trust fast. A new shop with good reviews on a well-known platform can feel safer to a stranger than an unknown name.
If you're just starting out, testing a product, or filling slow hours, a marketplace can be a smart move. Plenty of good local businesses got their first customers this way.
The real cost isn't just the fee
Most owners look at the fee first, and that matters. But the bigger costs are often the ones that don't show up as a line item.
Fees can change, and you don't get a vote
Whatever a platform charges today, it can charge differently tomorrow. Fee structures, ad programs and extra charges tend to shift over time, and as a seller you mostly find out when it happens. If most of your income runs through one app, a change on their end can squeeze your margins overnight.
The customer belongs to the platform
This is the big one. When someone orders or books through a marketplace, the platform usually owns that relationship. You may not get their email, you may not be able to contact them freely, and the next time they open the app, it may happily show them someone else.
You did the work of earning that customer. The platform keeps the connection.
You're listed right next to your competitors
On your own website, you're the only option on the page. On a marketplace, you're one result in a long list, often sitting right beside businesses offering something similar for less. That pushes everyone toward competing on price instead of on what makes you different.
Rules and rankings you can't control
Where you show up in search results, what your listing can say, which reviews stick, and whether your account stays active are all decided by someone else. Most of the time that's fine. When it isn't, there's usually not a local person you can sit down with to sort it out.
What owning your audience looks like
Owning your audience doesn't mean quitting the apps. It means having a home base that's yours. For most small businesses, that's:
- A website at your own domain that tells people who you are, what you offer and how to reach you directly.
- A direct way to buy or book, so repeat customers don't have to go back through a middleman.
- A simple customer list, like an email signup, so you can let people know about new products, open slots or seasonal hours.
- A Google listing that points to your site, not only to the marketplace.
When those pieces are in place, the marketplace becomes one door into your business instead of the only door.
A simple way to use both
Here's a balanced approach that works for a lot of owners:
- Use the marketplace for discovery. Let it introduce you to new people.
- Use your website for relationships. Make it easy for those people to come back to you directly the second time.
- Give people a reason to go direct. That might be easier booking, a full menu or product catalog, or simply getting to know the person behind the business.
One important note: many platforms have rules about steering customers away from their service. Read the terms for each one you use and stay within them. Things like your business name, your own website on your sign, your Google listing, and word of mouth are generally yours to promote however you like.
Do the math once
Sit down with a few months of marketplace statements and add up everything you paid: fees, ad spend, payment processing and any extras. Then multiply it out for a year. You don't need to be exact. You just want a rough sense of what renting is really costing you.
For some businesses, the number is small and totally worth it. For others, it's eye-opening. Either way, you'll make better decisions knowing it. If you have questions about how these costs affect your taxes, check with a tax professional.
Where a website fits in
A website isn't a replacement for every marketplace. It's the piece you own, the one that keeps working even if an app changes its rules or its fees.
I build custom websites for businesses around Morristown and the Lakeway Area, starting at $500 one-time, with managed hosting from $75 a month. You can see how that breaks down on the pricing page, and read more about how I approach web design for local businesses. Sites are built fast, mobile-first and set up so Google and AI search can find you directly.
If you'd like to see what your own home base could look like, I'll put together a free preview first, before you decide anything. When you're ready, you can get started here. No pressure, just a conversation with someone local.